There are two basic types of cancer salves
or pastes, those in which the action depends on toxic minerals
or acids and those that are herbal. Arsenic paste was mentioned
in the great Hindu epic, the Ramayana, 2500 years ago,
and was probably used until about the 1930s, even in mainstream
cancer hospitals in the U.S. Despite the centuries of controversy
surrounding such pastes, my investigations suggest that the
treatments, when skillfully employed, were highly successful.
Arsenic trisulfide is a component of Hoxsey's
yellow powder; and both he and Frederic Mohs combined bloodroot
with antimony in their primary escharotics. In other words,
even if there are arguments against the use of such minerals,
forms of arsenic as well as stibnite are found in many of the
most highly studied pastes, pastes that are used both in the
Hoxsey treatment and Mohs microsurgery methods as well as by
some Ayurvedic practitioners who claim that the arsenic can
be rendered nontoxic.
Were it not for their continued use, these
mineral pastes as well as nitric acid and similar chemical
preparations would be noted simply for the sake of connecting
the dots. However, much as modern science has attempted to
relegate such treatments to the list of quaint but no longer
relevant historic treatments, the pastes are not obsolete.
They are in use at such prestigious places as Harvard Medical
School and other institutions where Mohs microsurgery is considered
the treatment of choice for basal cell carcinomas. Nevertheless,
the pastes are officially regarded as archaic, not as ineffective,
not as belonging to the domain of quacks, not as useless, merely "not
modern." In other words, conventionally trained doctors
can dismiss cancer pastes because they practice modern medicine,
not archaic methods only covered in their medical history curriculum.
Herbal Salves and Suppression
of Information
Herbal preparations also have ancient
roots. The famous twelfth century German mystic, Hildegard
of Bingen, used a salve made of crushed violets, billy goat
tallow, and olive oil. Relying on her clairvoyance, she said
that the "vermes" (usually translated viruses)
died when they licked her salve.
The Inquisition, 1231-1834, played
an enormous role in Western history. It nearly eradicated the
practice of midwifery as well as most botanical methods of
treating illness. We learned in school that people came to
the New World in search of religious freedom, and though we
heard a little about witches, most of us were not told that
witches were usually women with a gift for healing that competed
with male dominated Medieval medicine.
Through the propaganda machine
of the Middle Ages, salves and ointments came to be associated
with quackery, a word whose etymology referred to boastful
claims rather than fraud. Quacksalver were salves, probably
containing mercury, that were widely sold in Western Europe
by people whose claims originated outside the walls of academia.
The original word, like so many others in our language, only
referred to a product, not an ethical judgment much less pseudoscience.
The aspersions cast on the products arose as a result of the
enterprise of opponents of an entirely different medical tradition.
Then
came the Age of Exploration and colonization of the Americas
and with this the reliance on herbs from the New World that
were not only the means for survival but also important export
commodities. Knowledge of botanical medicine was nearly extinct
in Europe so the use of the new American herbs, such as Phytolacca
americana, was learned from Native American medicine
men who gave to the white race the keys to survival in a
foreign land. More importantly, the transfer of wisdom in
this manner was not unique; it had been ongoing for centuries
if not since the beginning of Time.